teaching, literature, philosophy, theology, politics and whatever else I can think of

Saturday, May 10, 2008

are you a spiritual fruit? (a poorly organized, mostly uninformed rant)

Yesterday I saw two things that bothered me more than they probably should have. First, I was driving home from work yesterday and saw a bumper sticker that read GOD DESIRES SPIRITUAL FRUITS, NOT RELIGIOUS NUTS. I had seen this same bumper sticker before and didn't think much of it at the time, but yesterday it caught my attention and made me think for a long time about that word, "religion." Then last night I took my wife out to eat for Mother's Day and saw a guy in a black tee that made me look twice. The only word on the front was RELIGION, which had a circle around it and a line through it. The letters were white; the circle was red. On the black background I suppose it was intended to be an attention-grabber, and indeed it was. I watched the guy for a while, thinking he was probably a Richard Dawkins minion announcing his enlightened-ness to the world, but then he turned around and I saw written on the back of his shirt EMBRACE JESUS. "Oh," I said to my wife. "I see."

We've done a bad thing with this word "religion." There was a time when if you said "I am a religious person," everyone knew what you meant; they understood you to mean that you embraced and practiced a particular system of belief about the world and about God that imposed on you a certain quality of character and action. There were certainly varying degrees of assent to religion and varying degrees of hypocrisy; there were always people who believed and practiced wholeheartedly and people who were less than sincere about it. But everyone knew what "religion" meant.

Lately, though, the use of "religion" has become muddied. There are certain brands of Christianity - particularly Pentecostal denominations and the "non-denominational" denominations - in which this misuse of the word "religion" is very common. They often say things like, "I'm not religious. I'm spiritual." The difference? By "religion," they mean "empty religion" (which to them means liturgical and ritualistic traditions like Catholicism, liturgical Methodism, Lutheranism, etc.). By "spiritual," they mean "true religion," which must not be restricted by structure or ritual. If it isn't random, it isn't open to the Spirit. And so some find themselves saying things like, "Christianity isn't a religion; it's spirituality."

What this ignores or forgets is that the Bible itself refers to Christianity as "religion" and differentiates between empty religion and true religion: "If anyone thinks he is religious, and does not bridle his tongue but deceives in his heart, this man's religion is vain. Religion that is pure and undefiled before God and the Father is this: to visit orphans and widows in their affliction, and to keep oneself unstained from the world" (James 1:26-27). For Christianity to be "true religion," it must make a difference in your life and how you behave. If it does not, it is empty.

And there is another reason some are giving up "religion." In the current political and social arena, religion is the great whipping boy on which all the world's problems are blamed. War, racism, slavery, the oppression of women, child abuse, rape, people growing up to have all sorts of psychological problems, and that most heinous and yet hard-to-define crime, "intolerance," are all said to be caused by religion. If we were only rid of religion, we'd be rid of these problems. And so, many Christians have repudiated the word in favor of the chimeric and all-inclusive "spiritual."

They have plucked this word out of the tree of pop-culture, in which it means a vague belief in supernatural forces or beings, a belief in what is called "karma" (which has little to do with the Buddhist and Hindu understanding of karma), and a general sense of "different strokes for different folks." The danger is that the accompanying meaning is going to bleed through into Christianity. Christianity, for "spiritual" people, becomes less and less something that imposes definite responsibilities upon individuals, giving them all the benefits of a spiritual (in the proper sense) life without all the inconvenient requirements religion involves.

The irony is that this is exactly what the secularists who decry the evils of "religion" want. They will have won the battle if they can turn all religion into a vague "spiritualism" that makes no exclusive claims and requires nothing of its adherents except for them to be nice to people. In the effort to shield themselves from the attacks of religion's critics, they essentially raise the white flag and admit defeat.

Friday, May 9, 2008

"it's worth it all . . ."

Here's something we all used to know, then some folks came along and told us that this is a job only for the dull, the dimwitted, and those who don't want to live the life of a liberated woman.

Happy Mother's Day, all you moms. And thank you.

Wednesday, May 7, 2008

just shut 'em up

One of the first freedoms to go when a totalitarian regime rises is the freedom of speech and of ideas. The University of Toledo and Smith College are leading the way. How ironic that those who would otherwise tout intellectual freedom and "tolerance" are so intolerant of ideas they are unwilling (unable?) to engage and refute.

Saturday, May 3, 2008

this guy says it better than I did

On the First Things blog, Spengler says what I've been trying to say here all along (only he says it more lucidly and concisely):

"It is right and proper for the Jews to desire that all the world should worship YHWH in their own way, and inconsistent of them to object to the same desire on the part of Christians. But the critical point is that the dispute over the Easter prayer is a quarrel within Israel. Jews should worry only if and when Christians cease to pray for them, for that would signify that Christians had forgotten the root onto which the wild olive branches are grafted."

Here is the entire post. It is well worth reading.

Tuesday, April 29, 2008

Monday, April 28, 2008

liberation

A certain man teaches a child to write the alphabet. He gives him a piece of paper and a pencil and patiently teaches the boy each letter one by one, capital and lower case.

Then one day, the boy has learned not only to write the whole alphabet, but also words and sentences. He remarks to the teacher how stifling it is to be restricted to the piece of paper. Why can't he write anywhere else? The desk? The dictionary which sits on the desk?

After thought, the man takes the pencil and piece of paper away from the boy and says, Now you are no longer restricted to writing only on the piece of paper.

Sunday, April 27, 2008

the eternal demolition?

Picture this: You're taking a little time between two loads of laundry to read "Lines Composed a Few Miles Above Tintern Abbey." It's a Saturday off, the kids are down for a nap, and you're enjoying some quiet time with Wordsworth. Then comes a knock. Through the obscure glass oval window in the door, you see a man in a suit waiting patiently. Thinking it's a Witness ready to hand you a copy of Awake! or The Watchtower, you open and the visitor holds out a book of philosophy and says in a French accent, "Here is a very complicated theory of language and meaning that has no consequences or practical application. Want to learn it?"

In his April 6th blog post "French Theory in America," Stanley Fish writes about deconstruction theory and its influence and effects in the American academy. One of his main points is that, despite the fact that deconstruction has been used for and against political, religious and social agendas, deconstruction theory as articulated by its originators (Derrida, et al) does not have any necessary practical consequences. Fish writes

"It doesn't take anything away from us. We can still do all the things we have always done; we can still say that some things are true and others false, and believe it; we can still use words like better and worse and offer justifications for doing so. All we lose (if we have been persuaded by the deconstructive critique, that is) is a certain rationalist faith that there will someday be a final word, a last description that takes the accurate measure of everything. All that will have happened is that one account of what we know and how we know it - one epistemology - has been replaced by another, which means only that in the unlikely event you are asked "What's your epistemology?" you'll give a different answer than you would have given before. The world, and you, will go on pretty much in the same old way."

There are three problems with Fish's argument:

 - To say that there exists an unbridgeable separation between sign and signified, between language and the things that language describes, does have great consequences if it is really "true" (notice that Fish talks about whether or not deconstruction theory is valid while desperately avoiding the use of the words "true" or "false" to refer to it). As one friend of mine observed after reading Fish's article, reading the Constitution in light of deconstruction theory would have catastrophic practical consequences.

- If Fish is right, if deconstructionism in itself has no practical consequences and life will simply go on as long as people don't pervert deconstructionism for use in furthering their particular agendas, then why should anyone care about the theory?

- If deconstruction is indeed "true" or "right," then by its very nature it has an internal contradiction. Stated crudely, deconstruction theory says that there is no ultimate meaning in language, that there is an inevitable separation between words and the things words signify, that there is no such thing as truth or falsity outside of language; but we must use language itself to articulate the theory. As many critics of deconstruction have said before, isn't deconstruction theory invalidated by its own principles?

In philosophy there is a concept called the liar paradox. It involves statements like "This sentence is false," which swings like a pendulum between truth and falsity. If the sentence is true, then it is false; if it is false, then it is true. Deconstructionism seems to suffer from the same problem. And what can be made of a theory that tumbles in upon itself to infinity?

Monday, April 21, 2008

expelled, the nazis and the jews

One of the most controversial things about Expelled is its claim of a connection between the Nazis and Darwinism. The film asserts that, while Darwin himself wouldn't have supported the Nazis, much of the Nazi philosophy and policy towards the Jews and other "inferior" races came straight out of Darwinism. Darwinism, the film says, wasn't "sufficient" for the beliefs of the Nazis, but it was "necessary." (For more about the connection between National Socialism and Darwinism, see this article by David Klinghoffer).

It occurred to me while I was watching the film that this might be a dangerous tactic, amounting to almost an ad hominem attack. After all, don't many of religion's foes say things along the lines of, "All the major wars have been fought because of religion" and "All terrorists are religious," etc.? They righteously cite the Inquisition, the Crusades and the Salem Witch Trials in their attacks, assuring us that we'll all be nicer to each other if we rid ourselves of religion.

But then I realized that what Expelled does is actually a brilliant tactic. Before the section of the film about the Nazis, we see scenes of protesters with picket signs protesting "religion" (i.e., intelligent design) being taught in schools, many using words like "terrorist," and then we see Bill Mahr saying that it is not drugs or alcohol that should be regulated, but religion, since religion is the source of most wars and terrorism. Soon after, Ben Stein visits Aushwitz.

The point? We often do horrible things in God's name, but we don't need religion to be able to treat people like animals. The Nazis only needed the philosophy of Nietzsche and Darwinism. Stalin and Pol Pot only needed Communism (an anti-religion philosophy) and a certain obsession with power. History has a list of horrors committed in the name of religion, but it has an equally long list that has nothing to do with religion.

Evil parading under the guise of religion doesn't say something about religion; it says something about humanity. We'll use whatever is available to justify our wrongs, large or small.

Sunday, April 20, 2008

Friday, April 18, 2008

went and saw expelled this evening . . .

. . .  and it was well worth the sixteen bucks. I won't detail the whole film, but there are a few things I'd like to say about it.

- I read some reviews of Expelled ahead of time that complained of the film's lack of a specific definition of "evolution" and "intelligent design." While I did miss a detailed explanation of intelligent design, one of the interviewed scientists (his name escapes me now) did give a rough definition - namely, that ID posits that there is design in nature, and where we see design, one infers a designer. ID does not specify whether the designer is the Judeo-Christian God, Allah, Isis, or any other deity. A deist, a Muslim, a Jew, and a Christian can all equally accept the tenets of ID.

- Another of the interviewed scientists provided a helpful and often overlooked distinction. He said that when discussing "evolution" one must specify what is being talked about. "Evolution" might refer to simply change within given species over time, or it can refer to Darwinism itself, which posits that all the plethora of species came from one single-celled organism billions of years ago. Failure to make this distinction renders much discussion about evolution meaningless.

- The film is worth seeing, if for no other reason than being able to see Richard Dawkins make a fool of himself - as indeed he does towards the end of the documentary. It staggers the mind to think that such dumb words can escape the mouth of even a mildly educated person. I won't ruin it for anybody who hasn't seen the film. I will only say that I always thought he was a moron (I mean, I am a Christian theist, and he did write a book called The God Delusion), but now I know that he is. As Richard John Neuhaus says in the current issue of First Things, there used to be atheists one could respect intellectually (Marx, Neitzche, etc.). Now we have Dawkins. What a shame. If he keeps up, he'll probably drive some fence riders into being theists. Maybe even Christians.

BTW - for a good primer on intelligent design theory, see this article at Salvo Magazine.

Thursday, April 17, 2008

i hope obama heard these words . . .

. . . from Pope Benedict in his arrival ceremony:

"As the nation faces the increasingly complex political and ethical issues of our time, I am confident that the American people will find their religious beliefs a precious source of insight and an inspiration to pursue reasoned, responsible and respectful dialogue in the effort to build a more human and free society."

irony

In a speech given with the Pope at his arrival ceremony, President Bush had this to say:

"Here in America you'll find a nation of compassion. Americans believe that the measure of a free society is how we treat the weakest and most vulnerable among us. So each day citizens across america answer the universal call to feed the hungry and comfort the sick and care for the infirm. Each day across the world to eradicate disease, alleviate poverty, promote peace and bring the light of hope to places still mired in the darkness of tyranny and despair."

And yet America does not live up to its own standards, since the help and protection we offer to those who are strong enough to stand up for their own rights are not extended to those who cannot defend themselves, the weakest of the weak.

In defense of the President, though, his administration has done more to help the pro-life cause than any President in a long time. 

Also, it may be that the President was cleverly reminding his fellow Americans that, in fact, we treat our "weakest and most vulnerable" citizens in the same way Hitler treated Jews (an unpopular comparison, I know, but perhaps unpopular because it's true?).

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

the church of global warming

Let me begin this post with a cowardly disclaimer/confession: I consider myself a closet tree-hugger. Or perhaps a wannabe closet tree hugger. I grew up in a gorgeous area in central Alabama with lots of hills and beautiful forests. Now, when I go home to visit family I am grieved to see that more trees have been cut down. In place of a luscious mixture of pines and hardwoods have been planted perfectly uniform rows of young pines. The replanting makes me almost as mad as the clear cutting. The logging companies don't replace the hardwoods, just the pines, and they make the forest look like gated communities with clone houses and yards better manicured than my mother's fingernails. (BTW, on an unrelated subject, go here to see some hilarious ridicule of gated communities - just for giggles).

Just so you know.

On the First Things web site, R. R. Reno writes:

"The 1930s was a decade when many intellectuals were convinced that revolution, either fascist or communist, was the only answer to the social crisis of the times. It was during this era of political fervor that Simone Weil penned a rebuttal: 'It is not religion but revolution which is the opium of the masses.' Like so much of what Weil wrote, it's an arresting thought. And it's also one that is true on many levels" (full article here).

It seems that the new revolutionary battle cry is coming from the environmentalists. The current political landscape can almost be divided along the lines of how people feel about global warming. If you stand by Al Gore et al, you are automatically associated with a particular set of values, which more often than not includes a secular view of things. If you question global warming, you are usually associated with a different set of values, and usually with religion. Up until recently, Christians have been relatively uninterested in the current fashionable environmentalism. This seems strange to me because the God of Christianity has redeemed the whole creation and has placed man as lord of the earth.

What also strikes me is the fervor with which many environmentalists espouse their thought and practice. They speak of nature with the eloquence of mystics and rage with the fury of Christ turning over the moneychangers' tables at anyone who actively opposes their conclusions about the global weather trends. Indeed, some people's enthusiasm and devotion to the cause of saving the environment can only be described as religious. At the end of a class recently, I threw away some papers that I wouldn't need anymore and one of my classmates solemnly crouched by the garbage can and removed them. The scene was very strange - surreal even - and I am using no hyperbole when saying he did it "solemnly." I found out later that he was taking the papers out to put them in a recycling bin.

I think this is significant because of the lines along which the debate over global warming are drawn. The less religious people are, the more likely they are to believe in global warming. I have no hard statistics to defend that statement, but I think that most anyone who has looked very long at the cultural landscape would agree with me. The point that this proves is that people need some kind of religion. The 19th and 20th centuries saw a great rise in secularism, but accompanying these were new orthodoxies. It has been eugenics, feminism, Scientology has vied for the position, but I believe that environmentalism has nearly usurped the others as the religion of the secular. As Nigel Lawson says, "The new religion of global warming . . . resembles a Da Vinci Code of environmentalism" (quote lifted from a piece in First Things, originally from Lawson's book An Appeal to Reason: A Cool Look at Global Warming).
---------------------
UPDATE: Apparently, the extreme fervor of some environmentalists is having negative psychological effects. See the diagnosis.

you go, ben!

Ben Stein goes to school. BTW - here is a primer on ID over at Salvo.

Tuesday, April 15, 2008

it's about time somebody did this

This ought to rehabilitate 'em. Now if somebody will decide to replace capital punishment with caning, the crime rate will come down.